My challenge is to discover the origins of the
Bentley family in Oswego county, New York.
William Tyler
Bentley (1795?-1873) and his equally elusive wife, Olivia
Morgan Bentley (1790s?-1838), are hubby's 3d great-grandparents. They were born in New York state, married there, and had seven children there. They
might be the family shown in the 1830 Sandy Creek, NY census records under William T. Bentley's name.
In 1835, the Bentley family moved from Oswego to Elkhart, Indiana, where William bought a farm. With William and Olivia were their seven children:
Elizabeth E. Bentley (1821-1898)
Elisha Morgan Bentley (1824-1884)
Lucinda Helen Bentley (1825-1903),
see left
Lucy E. Bentley (1826-1900)
Simon Bentley (1828-1894)
Jane L. Bentley (1831 - ??)
Abbie Eliza Bentley (1832-1893)
In 1848, ten years after Olivia died, widower William took off for California, perhaps for the Gold Rush. Three years later, five of his seven children followed him to California.
Elizabeth Bentley married Emanuel
Light; Elisha Morgan Bentley married Charlotte
Raymond; Lucinda Bentley married Jonas
Shank; Lucy Bentley married Brice
Larimer (they were hubby's 2d great-gradparents); Simon Bentley married but was widowed by 1880 and drowned in 1894; Jane Bentley--well, she probably went to California; and Abbie Bentley definitely went to California, with her husband, Leonard L.
Curtis.
PS: A small mystery: In the
Goshen Democrat of May 4, 1898, the above obit appeared for William Tyler Bentley, who did indeed die at South Tule River, California. And he was the father of Lucy E. Bentley Larimer. But he died in 1873. So who died in 1898??