Shank, my Tombstone Tuesday for this week.
Lucinda's younger sister, Lucy E. Bentley Larimer, is hubby's great-great-grandma.
This death document confirms that Lucinda's parents were William T. Bentley of New York and Olivia Morgan Bentley of New York. Lucy's document says her mother was "Oliver" [sic] Morgan.
I'm so glad I didn't accept the name shown on family trees contributed by Ancestry users, who said "S.L. Hixon" was Lucy and Lucinda's mother. As if I needed another reason to look at the documentation for myself, this case shows how important it is to DIG DEEPER before coming to a conclusion!
Next challenge: Where in all of New York State were Lucy and Lucinda born? Where did they and their parents and siblings live?