Happy I Hired a Pro Genealogist

 

Earlier this year, I found an official Canadian publication from 1932 showing the naturalization certificate number for Italian-born Paolo Pietroniro (1897-1976), an in-law sibling in my husband's family tree. Actually, at the time, he became a British citizen through the Canadian naturalization process.

Researching what it would take to obtain Paolo's Canadian naturalization documents through the Access to Information and Privacy Act (ATIP), I learned three very important facts: (1) with the certificate number and date, I could skip a lengthy and expensive search process; (2) only a Canadian resident can request naturalization documents; (3) the cost for a naturalization file is just $5 through ATIP. I was pretty sure I had everything needed to make this request, except for my being ineligible to ask for the documents, since I don't live in Canada.

Finding someone in Canada to make the request

Initially, I approached three genealogy folks I know, all with ties to Canada, and asked for their informal assistance in obtaining the naturalization file. But of course these folks have busy lives and they weren't at all familiar with the ATIP process. I hadn't really thought this through. However, one of these nice folks suggested I contact a professional genealogist in Canada. An excellent idea!

So I asked for a video conference consult with Canadian pro genealogist Ellen Thompson-Jennings (well known as the Family History Hound from Hound on the Hunt). I read her blog regularly and I thought she would be a great help. Before we spoke, I had my documents ready to share and made notes about what, specifically, I hoped she could obtain for me.

Expertise and experience for the win

Ellen, who lives in Western Canada, was an absolute pleasure to work with. She listened carefully during our consult, looked at my paperwork, and confirmed that I had the right info to request a naturalization file. Best of all, she told me she had successfully made similar ATIP requests in the past. Whew. We agreed on a reasonable fee, including the $5 official fee, and she prepared the request for submission to Canadian authorities. Now all we had to do was wait.

Five weeks later, Ellen sent me an email with a pdf attachment: The 17 page electronic file for Paolo Pietroniro's naturalization! I learned he spoke, read, and wrote English as well as Italian. There was also lots of info about his trips from Montreal to Italy to visit family (exact dates of departure/arrival), and much more. I am delighted to have this file and am digging deeper into all the details in it.

As a bonus, Paolo's wife's naturalization documents were in the same electronic file. At top is one page from the naturalization of Filomena Damario Pietroniro (1895-1966). She became a Canadian citizen in 1939, having lived in the country for a decade. I was surprised to see that she made a mark instead of a signature. The page has a notation about "ignoring the art of writing," which I interpreted as meaning Filomena was not able to sign her name. In contrast, the documents revealed that Paolo was fluent in English, and he had a flowing signature, probably because he was an entrepreneur running a masonry business in Montreal.

I'm very happy a hired a pro genealogist for this project! Ellen's knowledge and experience were just what I needed to get the job done.

At the Beginning, A Sad End

I'm just beginning my research into the family background of two in-law ancestors in my husband's family: Piacentino "Peter" Pietroniro (1901-1979) and his wife, Anna Yurko Pietroniro (1910-1989). This couple married in 1929. I have the date and the officiant's name, and will be doing more research to identify the church.

Peter was an immigrant from Casacalenda, Italy who crossed the Atlantic in search of work and, like many from his area, settled in Cleveland, Ohio during the 1920s. 

Anna was one of 7 children born to immigrants from Hazlin, Czechoslovakia (now an area in Slovakia). Her father and some of her siblings worked in Cleveland steel mills. 

Multiple newspaper searches

Searching for the surnames Yurko and Pietroniro on multiple newspaper sites, I initially came across a surprising mention of Yurko in the Enakopravnost newspaper, a Slovenian-language publication in Cleveland that is in the OldNews.com database.  

Using the "Google Lens" app, I aimed the camera of my phone at the news item on my screen and took a photo of the translation.

It was a horrifically sad news report: Anna Yurko's 17-year-old nephew, Joseph Yurko, committed suicide by hanging himself after his widowed father "asked him to leave work during the holidays and stay at home with his four younger brothers and sisters."

Then I used GenealogyBank to look for any items about young Joseph's death and located a brief piece in the Cleveland Plain Dealer, p. 2 on 25 July 1947. The headline and subhead read:

Heartsick, Hangs Self--Boy, 17, broken up by request to quit job, says coroner.

This news item explained that the father had been unable to hire a housekeeper after the death of his wife the previous year. So during the summer months, when the father had to work but school was out, he wanted his oldest son to care for the younger children. But on the morning of July 24th, the father went down to the basement and found young Joseph's body 😥

Confirming Joseph's birth and death

Using the newspaper info as clues, I quickly found the mother's death a year earlier and learned that Joseph Robert Yurko was born on 11 June 1930 and died on 24 July 1947. His death cert confirms that death was due to suicide by hanging, a really tragic end to this high schooler's life. Joseph was buried in Calvary Cemetery in Cleveland, where many in the Yurko family were laid to rest. 

I was flabbergasted to see, from the 1950 US Census, that the Yurko family remained in the home where poor Joseph had died...his father had remarried and the household included the new wife, those younger children, plus a stepson.

So as I begin my Yurko and Pietroniro research, I've added all this sad news to the family tree.

"Beginning" is the first #52Ancestors genealogy prompt of 2025, from Amy Johnson Crow. 

Wordless Wednesday: Josef Yurko: from Czechoslovakia to Cleveland

A relative in my hubby's in-law family, Josef Yurko (1873-1954) was born in Hasalin, Czechoslovakia and marred Mary Gavalek (1879-1943) shortly before leaving for America. Their oldest son was born in Czechoslovakia and the other 4 sons and 2 daughters were born in Ohio, where they settled. Josef was a laborer, working in a foundry and later in a housing project. His oldest daughter, Anna C. Yurko (1910-1989), married Peter Pietroniro in 1929.

This photo is from one of Josef's naturalization documents, where he was sometimes called "Josef Yurkov."

Surname Saturday - Pietroniro of Casacalenda, Italy

Piacentino (Peter) Pietroniro, my step-children's grandfather, came from Casacalenda, Campobasso, Italy. But that's as far as we could go with his genealogy. Until now, thanks to Susan, a very kind genealogy angel, and the efficient Casacalenda officials.
After attending a talk by Toni McKeen about obtaining genealogical records from Italy, I wrote to the town officials of Casacalenda, requesting Peter's birth record and his family status record, if possible.

Today I received this extract of Peter's birth record. We already knew his birthday was February 27, 1901. What we had to determine was his parents' names. And now I know for sure that he's the son of Giovanni Antonio Pietroniro and Maria Teresa Mansi!

Susan looked up many Casacalenda records for me and found Peter's siblings plus his family four generations back in Italy. She also explained a bit about the area and why young men would leave in the 1920s (to find work). Thank you, Susan! And thank you, Casacalenda officials, for speeding this birth extract to me in only three weeks. 

Knowing Peter's parents allowed me to prepare detailed pedigree charts (downloaded for free from Misbach!) and show my step-children much more about their genealogical background on both sides of the family.

Now there are more Pietroniro mysteries to unravel: Peter came over with his brother, Paolo (Paul) Pietroniro. Paul settled in Canada with his wife Filomena and their children. Did other Pietroniro relatives immigrate?

52 Weeks- Disasters? Just the Usual, So Counting My Blessings

This week's challenge is "disasters" and I have to say, my family hasn't had any particularly unusual disasters. Let's leave aside WWII for the moment, of course. The disasters that made a big difference to my parents were more personal than environmental:

• My father Harold Burk's first heart attack was a disaster (for his health and for our family's finances). He lived nearly 20 years after that first attack, I'm happy to say.
• The Savoy Hilton Hotel in NYC being pulled down so the GM building could go up, another disaster--because my father lost his travel agency concession and never was able to secure another one, a devastating financial blow.
• My mother Daisy Burk's cancer was a disaster (she lived only 3 years after her diagnosis).

Despite these disasters, this week I'm counting my blessings. I have a wonderful extended family (that's getting larger all the time--now that I've met Cousin Lois and Cousin Lil, descended from Meyer and Tillie Mahler, my pat g-grandparents). And I'm counting my blessings that I have a bit of time and energy to trace back my ancestors and those of my extended family.

Right now I'm on the trail of the Pietroniro family from Casacalenda, Italy. Piacentino (Peter) Pietroniro and his brother Paolo (Paul) came from Italy to New York City on the Taormina on July 10, 1923. Paul went to Montreal, Peter went back and forth between Montreal and Cleveland and ultimately settled in Cleveland, marrying Anna Yurko (whose father I mentioned in my last blog entry). More info to come, I hope!